Table of Contents
Statement on grand jury’s refusal to indict lawmakers over video urging troops to ignore illegal orders
On Tuesday, a federal grand jury to indict a group of Democratic lawmakers who posted a video urging servicemembers to refuse to carry out illegal orders.
The following statement can be attributed to FIRELegal Director Will Creeley:
Let’s be clear: The lawmakers’ speech was plainly protected by the First Amendment.
In the United States, everyone — from a sitting U.S. senator to an everyday American — has the right to say our troops should refuse to carry out unlawful orders. Nobody should ever face arrest for doing so. And no prosecutor should ever argue otherwise.
All federal officials, from President Trump on down, take an oath to uphold the Constitution. Attempting to have political opponents — or anyone — jailed for their protected expression flatly violates that oath. The Framers intended the First Amendment to prohibit precisely such an abuse of power.
These charges should not have been presented to a grand jury. Thankfully, the brave Americans serving on that jury understood their awesome responsibility in our constitutional system. The prosecution ignored theirs.
In the United States, we shouldn’t have to thank a grand jury for preventing six elected officials from being arrested for exercising their First Amendment rights in a way that angered the president. But this is where we are.
Red lines are being crossed. Free speech and the rule of law are miracles of the American experiment. Now is the time for all Americans — regardless of party or politics — to demand our elected leaders honor their oaths to the Constitution.
Recent Articles
Get the latest free speech news and analysis from ÃÛÖÏãÌÒ.
FIREsues Bondi, Noem for censoring Facebook group and app reporting ICE activity
You talkin’ to me? New York City official wants to turn yellow cabs into speech police.
Two Universities. Two Posters. One First Amendment Problem.